Wednesday May 06, 2026

Extend and Pretend: The Psychology Behind Why Syndicators Won’t Sell

Everyone was waiting for the distressed deal flood. It never came. And Brian Sutton knows exactly why.

In Episode 5 of Lessons the Hard Way, Brian sits down with co-host Sam Chillingworth to break down the psychology behind why syndicators are holding on instead of selling — why extend and pretend took over the market — and what it actually feels like to be the operator sitting on a deal that isn't coming back.

Brian also makes a confession most operators in his position would never say out loud: MUST WATCH. He still believes in the model. And he explains exactly why.

In this episode:

• Why the expected flood of distressed deals became a slow drip instead

• The psychology of extend and pretend: denial, responsibility, and not wanting to post a loss

• Two choices in a bad syndication: sell for a loss or rescue capital.

• Why lenders were enabling the can-kicking just as much as operators

• Brian's confession: in 20 LP deals, a lot have gone south

• Why he still believes real estate generates more millionaires than any other asset class

• The fund model advantage: more flexibility, more options, better capital protection

• Contrarian capital: why the investors who make the most money buy when others won't

• A U-shaped recovery: what that means for timing and where Two Waters is positioning now

• Why this current downturn will produce the next great run in real estate

• What Brian would tell any investor sitting scared on the sidelines right now

Subscribe for weekly episodes. New deal autopsies and hard lessons every week.

🔗 Two Waters Capital: 2waterscapital.com

0:00 Cold open

0:36 Show intro

0:58 Welcome back: the buzzword right now is distress

1:27 Why distressed deals are trickling out instead of flooding the market

1:53 Brian was there: why he did not want to let go of his own bad deal

2:12 Nobody wants to post a loss

2:30 Single syndication in its infancy: why the market is especially fragile

2:59 The birth of coaching groups and new syndicators entering the market

3:29 Kicking the can: hoping the market comes back before investors find out

3:51 Two choices for a bad syndication: sell at a loss or rescue capital

4:34 The intention was never to lose money: giving operators credit where it is due

4:40 Survive until 25, extend and pretend: the mantras that kept deals alive

5:24 Bridge loans, capital calls, and convincing lenders to work with you

6:14 It will be a drip, not a fire hose: how the distress will slowly leak out

6:37 The psychology: what does it actually feel like to be that operator

7:05 Denial and responsibility: protecting capital vs. kicking the can

7:26 Your first loss is your least loss: when holding on stops protecting capital

7:49 Trapped in two ways: the vehicle and the psychology

8:09 Two Waters' response: learning from mistakes, moving to the fund model

8:38 Why funds give operators and LPs more options when deals go sideways

9:30 Still waiting for the next shoe to drop: operators and LPs in limbo

10:07 "The market is not coming back to save you"

10:24 Why people are not selling: denial on both the operator and LP side

10:58 LPs who signed up for passive income and stopped paying attention

11:18 Brian's confession

11:50 Why he still believes: real estate creates more millionaires than anything else

12:26 Investing direct vs. through a financial advisor: where the return actually goes

13:51 The next renaissance: real estate will come out of this downturn

14:19 Still optimistic and moving forward: Two Waters' current position

14:48 U-shaped recovery: what that looks like and why it matters for timing

15:08 Two Waters' first fund: two distressed assets bought at significant discount

15:48 Why these deals are hard to find and require deep local networks

16:12 Prices will not crater and will not rebound quickly: a slow leak for years

16:30 Investors got in for the right reasons, just potentially the wrong time

16:55 What to say to the investor sitting scared with capital on the sidelines

17:30 Contrarian capital: the investors who make the most money invest when others won't

17:59 The herd mentality of institutional capital and why it creates opportunity

18:30 Buy right in a down market and you will be rewarded for your courage

19:06 Closing thoughts: life is a journey and relationships are the point

20:07 Getting out of your own way: the hero syndrome that cost Brian the $10M deal

20:34 How that loss is shaping how Two Waters thinks about every future deal

21:14 Closing

#lessonsthehardway #twowaterscapital #realestatepodcast #realestateinvesting #syndication #distressedrealestate #multifamilyinvesting #accreditedinvestor #contrarian #realestatelessons

Comment (0)

No comments yet. Be the first to say something!